By Farid Mirbagheri*
The fast pace of developments regarding Iran makes analysis difficult and subject to changing circumstances. This also concerns the Western alliance hitherto thought to be a formidable front in global politics. The lack of a united front on Iran has further exposed a gap of some magnitude between Washington and her NATO allies, particularly Britain. Even differences over the war in Ukraine did not produce such a wide gap in Trans-Atlantic relations.
This division does not bode well either for Europe or for Iran. The continent is now facing the Russian bear on her eastern borders whilst she can no longer count on the unqualified support of the United States. The refusal of some major European powers to grant permission to US fighter planes to enter their air space in the war with Iran was an act of open defiance of their most powerful ally and the strongest military force on the planet. The war in Ukraine is draining their economy with an uncertain outcome in the military arena. Should things stay the way they are Europe will find it increasingly difficult to maintain her position of influence in global affairs.
Since WW II all major developments inside Iran have taken place with agreement between Washington and London. The withdrawal of British as well as Soviet troops from Iran after the War, the events of 1953 and the upheaval of 1978 all happened with the complicit agreement of the United Kingdom and the United States. Now that the country is in the throes of fundamental change, discord between the two Western capitals has delayed and/or blocked the emergence of a new Iran.
The cancellation of insurance services to ships moving in the Persian Gulf by the Lloyds of London in the first days of the war was meant to hike oil prices that could in turn apply pressure on the US President to reconsider his policy on Iran. The immediate presidential decree by Donald Trump, however, to offer an American alternative to Lloyds mitigated the impact and prevented a surge in oil prices.
Refusing permission to the Pentagon to use Diego Garcia Base in the Indian Ocean in her military campaign against the Islamic Republic in Iran further demonstrated the extent of division between London and Washington regarding Iran. Turning down US call for assistance in opening and keeping open the Straits of Hormoz, through which 20 percent of the world’s oil travels, was an irrefutable evidence that Downing Street considers British interests over Iran in direct conflict with the current developments.
A brief survey of the Iranian political landscape shows that neither the UK nor the US have been able to effect any significant shift inside the country when acting alone. For instance, the so-called reformist group in the country that has consistently enjoyed British backing was not able to triumph over the hardliners and has now been pushed to the margins. Equally, despite enjoying the strongest military force and the largest economy in the world, the full military and intelligence cooperation and participation of Israel and the presence of a viable and widely popular political alternative in the person of the Iranian Crown Prince residing in America, the US has not been able to topple the Islamic Republic.
The continuation of the status-quo cannot be in the interest of London or Washington. The Revolutionary Guards, IRGC, have now assumed almost full political control of the country. They are more Russophile and pro-China than Anglophile, and harbour a particular dislike for the ‘reformist’ faction supported by the UK. In all likelihood the prolongation of the current situation will lead to greater Russian and Chinese influence in the country, which cannot be in line with British interests.
As for the United States a new secular and democratic Iran can have many advantages. Firstly, Iran could be included in the Abraham Accord providing greater regional stability. Secondly, the collapse of the Islamic Republic would put an end to a constant source of anti-Americanism in the Middle East. Finally, the promises of heavy investment in the US by Saudi Arabia and the Persian Gulf countries would have a much higher chance of being realized. Iran will also need hundreds if not trillions of dollars in investment in her economy, for which the rich resources of the country more than adequately provide guarantees.
It is a funny old world. The few decide and the many have to accept. Nearly half a century of decimation, decadence, and misery for Iran and Iranians must be enough for decision makers to put aside their difference and forge a policy on Iran that, whilst promoting their interests, would not deny the freedom for which millions of Iranians have given their lives.
*Farid Mirbagheri is a Professor of International Relations and Senior Fellow at Strategy International




