A Cypriot court has acquitted a South African businessman and bodybuilding coach who spent 18 months in custody awaiting trial on rape and assault charges, ruling that prosecutors failed to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.
Joseph Davidson, 53, had denied all allegations against him and claimed from the outset that the accusations were part of a plan by his former wife and her relatives to gain control of gold coins and other assets he owned.
The Permanent Criminal Court in Larnaca cleared Davidson on May 4 in a unanimous 58-page ruling that sharply criticised the credibility of the complainants and highlighted investigative omissions by police.
According to the ruling, Davidson married his Lithuanian wife in South Africa in 2016 before the family later relocated to Cyprus and settled in a multi-storey property in Kalavasos.
The couple also operated a health food business in Limassol.
The case centred on allegations made after Davidson travelled to Texas with his wife and her sister in October 2024.
While in the United States, the two women returned to Cyprus without informing him and later filed complaints with the police on Nov. 10, 2024, accusing him of rape and violent assaults.
When Davidson returned to Cyprus, police arrested him and he remained in custody until his acquittal.
The court said Davidson had told investigators from the beginning that he believed the complaint was financially motivated and linked to 189 gold coins he kept partly in a bank safe deposit box and partly at the family home in Kalavasos.
The judges criticised investigators for failing to examine those claims despite Davidson repeatedly raising them during the investigation.
The ruling referred to several actions by Davidson’s wife that the court said suggested planning, including a divorce application filed before the couple travelled to the United States, the withdrawal of his access to a safe deposit box, visits to the bank vault and the changing of locks at the family home while he was abroad.
The court said those actions, viewed collectively, indicated that Davidson’s wife had “acted according to a plan”.
During the trial, defence lawyer Elias Stephanou challenged the evidence given by Davidson’s former wife, her sister and their mother, exposing what the court described as major contradictions, omissions and inconsistencies in their testimony.
The court found that some allegations changed over time and that new details were introduced during testimony that had not previously been mentioned to the police.

In one example highlighted in the ruling, the complainant initially told police the alleged rape occurred in February 2022 before later changing the date to February 2023.
The judges also referred to video evidence showing Davidson’s wife present while gold coins were placed in the safe deposit box, contradicting her claim that she did not know the coins existed.
The court said the testimony of Davidson’s former wife had been so seriously undermined during cross-examination that it could not be accepted on any point.
Judges also said Davidson remained consistent throughout his testimony and showed no signs of attempting to conceal or distort facts despite extensive questioning.
The ruling stated that reasonable doubt in the case was substantial and affected the core of the prosecution’s allegations.
“The existence of reasonable doubts does not permit conviction, regardless of the seriousness of the accusations,” the court said.
Following his acquittal, Davidson told Phileleftheros he planned to pursue legal action to recover assets he claims were taken from him.
Speaking during an interview in Kiti, he said the emotional impact of the case on him and his two daughters had been worse than losing millions of euros.
Davidson also criticised the criminal justice system, saying police ignored his explanations from the beginning and failed to investigate evidence he believed supported his account.
He said prison conditions in some wings of the Central Prison were dangerous, describing violence, drug trafficking and overcrowding, although he praised prison officers for treating him fairly and supporting him during his detention.




