Woman partially blinded at 17 wins fight over eye doctor’s appeal

Relevant News

The Court of Appeal on Wednesday refused to let an ophthalmologist add 16 new grounds to his appeal against an order to pay a woman more than 82,000 euros over damage to her eyesight. The woman, who was 17 and living in Paphos when her eye problems began, has been pursuing the case since 2009.

In a unanimous ruling dated 18 November, the court found that the application involved excessive and unjustified delay, and that granting it would adversely affect the woman’s rights and make it harder for the case to be heard within a reasonable time. It ordered the ophthalmologist to pay 2,000 euros in costs to the woman.

The woman, who had been short-sighted since childhood and wore a particular brand of contact lenses, developed irritation and an infection in her left eye in September 2006. After seeing doctors in Cyprus, she was treated for a long period in Athens by the ophthalmologist. When the treatment did not work, she went to London in March 2007 and was diagnosed with acanthamoeba keratitis. The condition left her with permanent damage, including partial blindness in her left eye, sensitivity to light and a scar on her cornea.

In 2009 she sued six defendants: the contact lens manufacturers and importers, the Republic of Cyprus over the lenses’ import, and the ophthalmologist, whom she accused of a lack of skill and care. On 28 April 2021, Paphos District Court ruled against the ophthalmologist and awarded her 70,000 euros in general damages, 7,000 euros for future expenses and 5,347.45 euros in special damages, plus interest and costs. Her claims against the other five defendants were dismissed. The ophthalmologist appealed on 9 June 2021 on 11 grounds, and the woman filed her own appeal, which is pending.

The application

On 7 July 2026, the ophthalmologist applied to add a new paragraph to one of his existing grounds and 16 further grounds. His side argued that he had wanted to study the first-instance judgment with a lawyer in Greece, and that his lawyers did not have the full transcripts when the original appeal was prepared. Having recently received and studied them, they said, they had found it necessary to add new grounds to present his case more fully.

The woman’s side opposed the application, calling it abusive, late and inadequately justified. It said he was trying to restructure the appeal with new, standalone claims that were either already known or could have been raised from the start.

The court’s reasoning

Amendments to a notice of appeal require the court’s permission and must serve the Overriding Objective of dealing with cases fairly and at proportionate cost, the court said.

In its ruling, the court found procedural shortcomings in the application, but gave most weight to the delay. The sworn statement supporting it did not say when the study of the judgment in Greece began, how long it took, when the transcripts were requested or when the need to amend the appeal arose. No specific and adequate explanation was given for the five years it took to make the application. Because the appeal had already been set down for a pre-trial hearing, granting the request could also lead to a significant postponement.

The proposed amendment was extensive. Eleven of the new grounds were linked to existing ones and five had no direct connection to them, which the court considered a clear attempt to rebuild the appeal on a new, wider basis.

The woman had been waiting more than five years for the appeal to be heard. Granting the application would force her to extend her preparation, at extra time and cost, and an award of costs would not adequately compensate her, the court said. Allowing the amendment would therefore go against the Overriding Objective.

Follow en.philenews on Google News and be the first to know all the news about Cyprus and the world.