No hostels, no day centres: judge lists gaps in child justice

Relevant News

Missing facilities and services that the law provides for children in conflict with the law often force Children’s Court judges to impose different sentences from those they should, Supreme Court judge Elena Efraim said.

Speaking at a seminar on minors and offending, organised by the School of Judges with the Law Office of the Republic, Efraim said the gaps caused judges frustration and real difficulty, because they did not have all the options for dealing with children that the 2021 Children in Conflict with the Law Law gives them.

Some steps are under way. Eight permanent probation officer posts have been approved in the 2027 budget, Efraim said. The lack of probation officers has made the Children’s Court’s work particularly difficult, because it significantly limits the ways the court can deal with a child. A detention area for children is also being set up within the Central Prisons, after the lack of a suitable facility prevented the right sentence being imposed in some cases. Its operating regulations are pending, and it is expected to be ready at the end of 2027.

Three challenges

Efraim set out three challenges, which she said the Law Office shared. The first was to achieve full implementation of the law as quickly as possible, so that it could be said to have been “not only enacted but also fully and effectively implemented”.

The second was ambiguities, gaps and inconsistencies in the law, on both procedural and substantive matters, which make it hard for the courts, the Law Office and police to apply. A committee of the Law Office’s criminal division has been set up to examine the law.

The third was continuous training for judges and everyone else involved, so that they know how best to deal with child offenders, with the aim of reintegrating them into society.

Problems in practice

Efraim listed several problems that have arisen in applying the law. Children’s Court judges have been appointed but also carry out duties in other courts, and have said it is difficult to meet both sets of demands.

The law requires the Children’s Court to be housed separately from other courts, but allows it to share premises until then. It also requires police to ensure that a child held on remand does not come into contact with any adult accused of another offence when being taken to and from court or while waiting. Only the Paphos and Famagusta courts can provide such a space. In the Nicosia, Limassol and Larnaca districts, there is nowhere suitable for a child to wait without coming into contact with other people at court, particularly those involved in the case against them.

Reports by experts such as welfare officers or mental health services, which the law requires before a custodial sentence, are severely delayed, meaning cases are not completed as quickly as possible.

There is also a lack of programmes and facilities that the law provides for, including programmes to improve parenting skills, education and activity programmes, day centres for children to take part in education, work or activities, and open and closed hostels.

Gaps in the law

According to Efraim, it is unclear whether the Children’s Court keeps jurisdiction once a child turns 21 after a case has been filed. The law provides for cases to be referred from a District Court to the Children’s Court, but not the other way round, which is needed when it emerges that a person is over 21, or was over 18 when the offence was committed. An explicit provision for referring a case to the Children’s Court of another district would also be useful.

The provision on holding a child on remand in a children’s detention facility is unclear, because it confuses the detention of suspects with that of accused people. The Law Office sent a proposal to amend it, but the Ministry of Justice and Public Order sent a bill that needs improvement, so the Law Office will propose a full revision and replacement of the article.

Efraim described the law as a much-needed and very positive step.

Follow en.philenews on Google News and be the first to know all the news about Cyprus and the world.