Demetrios Zoppos on technology, innovation, and Cyprus’s place in the world that’s coming.
The post office
A few weeks ago I went to collect a registered letter from the post office. The notice was sent to an old address, so I brought a photo of it on my phone, barcode and all. The clerk did not scan the barcode. She read my name, sorted through a pile of envelopes by hand and found the letter. Having checked my ID, she had me sign an electronic pad, then add my full name and identity number, more than the transaction needed. And she reprimanded me for not bringing the paper notice so that I could sign that too.
Nothing about the exchange was unusual, which is the point. Anyone who deals with the Cypriot state, central or local, knows the ritual: a certificate from one office for another office that already holds the same information, a stamp, a signature, a copy of the copy. The clerk was not being difficult. She was protecting herself.
The notary in Famagusta
It was not always so. Around 1300, in a Famagusta rich on Levantine trade, a Genoese notary named Lamberto di Sambuceto drew up the paperwork of commerce. His registers survive in the archives of Genoa, and among them are powers of attorney: merchants who could not stay on the island appointing someone to collect their debts in their name.
A merchant who had never met the notary could still trust the deed, because it was authenticated once and done properly. Every deed followed the same form: an invocation, the parties and their business, then the place and the named witnesses. The original stayed in the notary’s register, and behind it stood the Genoese commune’s court in Famagusta, with an officer empowered to seize a defaulting debtor’s goods. Today, one Cypriot department often asks again for the same certificate the one next door already holds.
Decision insurance
In an earlier column I argued that the state’s paperwork works as a priority system, deciding who gets served and when. It has a second function, which explains why it multiplies even when there is no queue to jump. The post office had no such queue; my letter was sitting in the pile. The paper is decision insurance.
Approve something that later goes wrong and you are blamed. Approve it quickly and nobody thanks you. Delay it, or simply say no, and almost nobody notices. Every extra signed document moves a little potential blame off the official and onto the file, so asking for one more is always rational. James Q. Wilson, the great student of bureaucracy, observed that where an agency’s results cannot be seen, its people are judged on whether they followed procedure, and they behave accordingly. The mountain of paper is a signal of care aimed not at the citizen but upwards, at managers, auditors and any future inquiry.
Beneath it sits a deeper gap. In Cyprus it is often unclear whether a decision is political or administrative. Officials fear owning it; politicians often prefer to leave it with officials, so that if it goes wrong the cost lands elsewhere. The decision is left an orphan, and the citizen struggles to find out who took it, on what basis, or how to object. And the citizen pays the official’s insurance premium in delays.
Fuzzy processes
Insurance of this kind breeds fuzzy processes. A procedure that ought to be standard collects discretionary steps from well-meaning, often junior officials who fear blame, and the steps harden into local habit. My family’s division of ancestral land took three decades, and at the very end the Nicosia district office still followed a somewhat different procedure from the one in Paphos, under the same law.
Land transfer shows the cost. Elsewhere in Europe, lawyers or notaries hold the money until the transfer is registered, so trust between professionals replaces physical presence. In Cyprus, buyer and seller, or someone holding their power of attorney, must appear at the land registry, with the tax prepaid and the money changing hands at that moment. Presence substitutes for a trust layer that was never built. As cheques disappear, people route around the gap with whatever instant payment they can find.
The perfect alibi
Artificial intelligence breaks this in two ways. The first is that paper stops working as insurance. When any document can be generated in seconds, and forged almost as fast, a thick file no longer proves that anyone took care. Frightened officials will retreat to what machines find hardest to fake: wet signatures, original stamps, attendance in person.
The second is subtler. The machine becomes the perfect decision insurance, because “the system decided” moves blame further than any certificate. Nobody will announce that consequential decisions are being automated; fear will do it by default. The department is busy, the official is junior, the system offers an answer, and nobody wants to be the one who overruled it. Europe already requires human oversight of high-risk systems, but a rule that demands a human means little if the human is afraid to disagree. AI systems are not rules in code but probabilities: the same case can get a different answer, and nobody can say exactly why. Arbitrariness that hid in discretion returns at scale, with no one’s signature on it.
The fear stays; only the cover changes. Yesterday it was a stamp. Tomorrow it will be the system’s answer.
Standardise, then automate
First, authenticate once. What one part of the state has verified, every other part should accept without asking the citizen again. The EU calls this the once-only principle; every member state has signed up to it, and Estonia built its digital state on it.
Second, make every consequential decision a record: who decided, on what basis, for what reasons, and how to object. A crisp decision is the document worth producing, not the certificates around it. Where a machine assists, the record says so, and a named person still signs.
Third, protect the official who decides properly. In principle, officials acting in good faith are already protected. But good faith is judged after the event, by an audit or an inquiry, on the evidence of the file, so the safest file is the thickest. Company law in many countries does better: it sets out in advance what a sound process looks like, and protects directors who can show they followed it. Officials need the same. The objection is that this shields the careless. It does the opposite: abuse thrives in fuzzy decisions, and a recorded decision with reasons and a route of appeal is far harder to bend than a pile of certificates with no visible decider.
A person who answers
Seven hundred years on, Lamberto’s register still tells us who authorised whom, and for what. That is the standard a modern state should meet: one authentication, a decision anyone can read, and a person who answers for it, made safe enough to say yes. The machines will run on whatever layer of trust we give them. They will also run on electricity, and when we hand them our thinking, its cost becomes the cost of power. That is where I will turn next.
Demetrios Zoppos is a Partner at 33East. The views expressed are exclusively his own.




