The Nicosia Criminal Court on Monday told the defence in the ‘golden passports’ trial of former transport minister Marios Demetriades and others to specify its objections to seized documents and electronic data. The direction came after a defence lawyer said the material, which he put at nine million emails, was difficult to itemise.
The court said that if each item could not be identified individually, the disputed material should at least be categorised. The defence said it would do so and asked for time, and the court set the case for 23 November.
After a break in the hearing, the court had asked the defence which specific communications it considered protected by legal professional privilege, and where it believed the terms of the court orders had been breached.
“You mean I should list the nine million emails? The volume is huge, your honour,” replied Ilias Stefanou, who represents six of the defendants. As examples, he cited 1,400 messages between defendants, 198,000 emails with the firm’s clients, 800 meetings with clients and 149,814 photographs. He said the seized material included details of private life and communications unrelated to the case.
At the centre of the hearing was a defence request for a single “trial within a trial” to examine objections concerning privilege, the protection of communications, the legality of how the evidence was obtained and its relevance to the charge sheet.
Stefanou contended that the objections rested on separate but related grounds that could be examined in a single procedure. The first was the protection of privilege. The second was the alleged breach of the terms of the search warrants and access orders. Despite the restrictions and safeguards set by the court, he said, police had accessed all the electronic data without limiting themselves to the time period and the corruption offences under investigation. In his view, collecting material beyond the scope of the court orders raised issues of proportionality and of the constitutionally protected confidentiality of communications.
The defence also questioned the relevance of evidence concerning investors who, it said, are not included in the charge sheet, maintaining that the legality and relevance of the evidence should be examined together.
For the prosecution, Haris Karaolidou countered that the objections were general and vague and did not adequately identify the evidence concerned or the grounds for challenging it. Examining them in the way the defence proposed would effectively mean presenting the evidence twice, she said, and she disagreed that relevance should be examined together with legality.
Karaolidou said the orders had been issued with safeguards and that the search had been carried out using keywords. She did not rule out a trial within a trial on the search warrant for specific items of evidence, but opposed grouping all the objections together.
The case concerns the exceptional naturalisation of 19 investors from Asia. Demetriades and nine other individuals and companies face a total of 84 charges, including corruption, bribery, influence peddling, conspiracy to defraud, VAT fraud and money laundering. The former minister is alleged to have intervened in the examination of naturalisation applications handled by the law firm of his father and brothers. Other charges relate to the alleged unjustified use of a reduced 5 per cent VAT rate and the alleged use of fictitious invoices for money transfers.




