Advocate finds patient rights breached in 12 of 23 GHS transfer scenarios

Relevant News

Patients moved between hospitals in the General Health System (GHS) can be left without anyone clearly responsible for their care, the Patients’ Advocate has warned. A new report from the Advocate found that patients’ rights were breached in 12 of 23 typical referral and transfer scenarios.

Under the current framework, six more of the scenarios mapped in the report were rated critical, and only five complied with the rules. About 380 hospital admissions a month involve patients transferred from another facility, according to Health Insurance Organisation (HIO) figures cited in the report. The true scale of the problem is unknown, however, because refusals, delays and disagreements between providers are not recorded.

The report’s central finding is that the law requires a patient to be admitted either where they are, or at a suitable facility they are transferred to. It does not clearly set out when the receiving hospital has taken the patient over, or who is responsible until that happens.

In practice, the Advocate said, whether a hospital has accepted a patient is often decided through verbal arrangements. Patients can end up being passed from hospital to hospital, from accident and emergency (A&E) to their treating doctor, or from their treating doctor to another A&E, without being admitted until the dispute is settled. The report warns that the current framework can leave the patient “caught in the middle”.

“A phone call is not a handover, and a ‘go elsewhere’ recommendation is not a referral. When providers disagree, the patient should already be receiving care, not waiting for the disagreement to be resolved,” the Advocate said.

Beds and disputes

The report also found there is no central register of available beds. When a hospital says it has no beds, there is no central way to check whether that is true.

Nor is there any body with the authority to decide quickly who takes on a patient when two hospitals disagree. As a result, a dispute between providers can turn into a wait for the patient.

Complex patients, who need more care and cost more to treat, are the most exposed, according to the report. It says it did not find discrimination in any specific case, but that the system currently lacks the safeguards that would prevent it.

Proposals

The Advocate proposes a clear rule. No referral or transfer should be considered complete until another suitable facility has accepted the patient in writing and by name. Until then, the hospital the patient first went to should remain responsible.

The report also calls for:

  • a written referral for every transfer
  • a record of every refusal
  • a mandatory stand-in when the treating doctor is unavailable
  • an HIO coordinator with the power to decide within hours when hospitals disagree
  • a central register of available beds

The report makes clear that it is not a finding on any specific incident and does not blame particular people or hospitals. Its conclusion is systemic: not all the safeguards needed to ensure a patient is never left between two providers without someone clearly responsible for them are currently in place.

Follow en.philenews on Google News and be the first to know all the news about Cyprus and the world.