Prime Video’s new series Young Sherlock, executive produced and directed by Guy Ritchie, promises a fresh take on the legendary detective’s early years. Across eight episodes, this ambitious project transports us to 19th-century Oxford, where a 19-year-old Sherlock gets tangled in a global conspiracy.
The production stands out for its top-tier aesthetic, with the costume design stealing the show. Precise attention to detail—from rich silks to intricate cufflinks—breathes real life into the period setting. Furthermore, the supporting cast delivers standout moments, with Colin Firth and a fiery Dónal Finn as young Moriarty commanding the screen.
However, the show suffers from a severe identity crisis. The script is overloaded with flimsy subplots, international espionage, and buried family secrets, leaving the main plot no room to breathe. The relentless pacing simply rushes from one twist to the next, sacrificing genuine mystery for non-stop action.
The biggest issue lies with lead actor Hero Fiennes Tiffin. Instead of the sharp intellect and eccentricities expected of Sherlock, his performance lacks expression, coming across more like an awkward waiter than a brilliant mind. His lack of chemistry with the rest of the cast becomes even more striking next to the charismatic Finn, who completely overshadows him in every shared scene.
At the same time, Guy Ritchie’s trademark direction—packed with fast-cut editing and slow-motion fight sequences—feels dated compared to his work fifteen years ago, while the other directors merely imitate his style with little success.
The Verdict: Mediocre. While it boasts a few fun action beats and stunning costumes, the series gets lost in cheap thrills, leaving the detective’s legend frustratingly untapped.
Read more:
