Cyprus violated rights of German defendant in occupied north properties case, court rules

Relevant News

Nicosia Criminal Court on Wednesday unanimously ruled that police violated a German woman’s constitutional rights when they searched her luggage and seized evidence, excluding materials from a case involving 46 charges related to Greek Cypriot properties in occupied northern Cyprus.

The court found that officers conducted the search and seizure in breach of the defendant’s constitutional protections, rendering the evidence inadmissible. The ruling emerged from a “trial within a trial” procedure that examined whether police collected the evidence lawfully.

“At this stage, the defendant’s constitutional rights were violated. The search and seizure of a series of exhibits was impermissible and unconstitutional,” presiding judge Nikolas Georgiades said in announcing key points from the 75-page decision.

The German estate agent, who followed proceedings through an interpreter, faces charges spanning 2023-2024 including transactions, advertising, promotion and illegal use of properties in the occupied territories, as well as money laundering from illegal activities.

Court finds police breached constitutional rights during airport search

Georgiades said the court evaluated testimony from 10 defence witnesses and prosecution witnesses before determining that whilst the airport arrest procedure was lawful, the subsequent search of the defendant’s personal items was problematic.

The court found that although police informed the woman of her rights in German and she understood she was under arrest, the search and seizure failed to meet legal and jurisprudential requirements.

The court ruled that the testimony from the police officer who conducted the search was “general and vague”. The ruling stated that the seizure of the defendant’s phone, hard drive and other documents was not based on reasonable suspicion directly connected to the alleged offences under investigation.

“The initial seizure was done as routine,” Georgiades said, adding that “the circumstances create doubt” and the prosecution failed to prove the procedure’s lawfulness.

The court cited Cypriot, European, American and Canadian jurisprudence on the principle of proportionality, noting that police authority to search and seize during an arrest cannot be unlimited. Officers must establish sufficient reason and a direct relationship between seized items and the substance of the case, which was not demonstrated here, the ruling stated.

The court also identified a violation of the defendant’s right to legal counsel. Although police testified that she did not request a lawyer, judges ruled this did not constitute valid waiver of her right.

“We do not accept that the phrase ‘did not request representation’ constitutes waiver of the right to counsel,” Georgiades said.

According to the reasoning, waiver of such a fundamental right must be “informed and expressed without any doubt”, with the suspect having full awareness of the consequences. This was not proven, the court found.

The court said that searching her luggage was an investigative act related to the right against self-incrimination. Therefore, the consent she gave by signing the relevant form, without a lawyer present and without full explanation of the consequences of refusal, was deemed invalid.

Defence lawyer requests return of seized computers and documents

Following the ruling, prosecution representative Anna Mattheou told the court that “the excluded evidence affects the case” and requested a 10-day adjournment for the Law Office to study its next steps.

Defence counsel Sotiris Argyrou agreed to the adjournment request and immediately raised the issue of returning the seized items, including computers and documents, since the court ruled them inadmissible as evidence.

The court scheduled the next hearing for 20 October at 9:00 a.m. and ordered the defendant to remain in custody until then.

The case concerns properties in the occupied north of Cyprus, which has been under Turkish military control since 1974 following Turkey’s invasion. The Republic of Cyprus considers any property transactions in the occupied territories illegal, as it does not recognise the self-declared Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, which only Turkey recognises.

Greek Cypriots who fled or were expelled during the 1974 conflict retain legal ownership of properties in the occupied areas under Republic of Cyprus and European Court of Human Rights rulings.

Read more:

Follow en.philenews on Google News and be the first to know all the news about Cyprus and the world.