Could the data we leave behind online help build a more equal world? Maurizio Ferraris makes the case

Relevant News

Italian philosopher Maurizio Ferraris wants human need to carry more weight in how society distributes wealth. His starting point is the role that luck plays in what people achieve, from the family they are born into to the schools they attend.

“It’s not a merit to be born in a good family with rich parents,” he said. He calls for a shift from a “tyranny of merit” to a “democracy of need”. As production becomes more automated, he argues, society must reconsider how people share in its wealth.

His proposal, Webfare, would pool the data people generate in everyday digital life and seek to earn revenue from it. Participation would be voluntary, and most of any proceeds would go to people who need support, he explains.

Ferraris, professor of theoretical philosophy at the University of Turin and president of LabOnt – Center for Ontology, spoke to en.philenews, on 3 November, ahead of a public lecture at the American University of Beirut – Mediterraneo in Paphos.

The talk formed part of the university’s AI Literacy initiative, conceived and led by Dr Ana Ilievska, assistant professor of global liberal arts in the Faculty of Arts and Sciences. Ilievska invited Ferraris to speak and translated his 2024 book, Webfare: A Manifesto for Digital Well-Being, into English.

Why need before merit

Ferraris cites Michael Sandel’s 2020 book The Tyranny of Merit in his own Webfare manifesto. Sandel argues that people who succeed tend to discount the luck and opportunities that helped them. Treating market rewards as a measure of what people deserve, in Sandel’s view, corrodes solidarity.

Ferraris also cites Karl Marx’s 1875 Critique of the Gotha Programme, which envisages distribution according to need in a higher phase of communist society, once productive capacity has expanded. Ferraris takes up that principle in the context of automation. People still have needs as machines take over more of the work of meeting them. In his account, the traces people leave as they go about their lives can generate value that could be used to meet some of those needs.

In the interview, Ferraris argued that exceptional ability cannot be the foundation of a policy intended to serve everyone. He expresses this provocatively, calling for “a politics for stupids”.

“I include myself in this list,” he added.

His point is that political institutions must address ordinary people’s needs, rather than assume a population made up of unusually intelligent, educated citizens.

Data, he suggests, offer a way to recognise a contribution regardless of intellectual distinction. He contrasts a genius with someone who spends ten hours scrolling through TikTok. The second person’s activity may be at least as useful for understanding tastes and profiling behaviour.

How Webfare would use the value of our data

Under Webfare, institutions Ferraris calls “Virtue Banks” would pool the data people generate in everyday life. In his example, a million customers would authorise a bank to request their data from online platforms.

He compares the process with the way a bank seeks to generate value from the financial assets entrusted to it. Here, the resource would be records of human activity. Their economic potential, he argues, becomes accessible when they are brought together and analysed on a large scale.

The bank would retain a share of any proceeds. “The major part of the wealth should be redistributed to those who are in need,” Ferraris said. He points to the social role of banking foundations as a comparison for how proceeds could reach communities.

Ferraris presents this as a way for people to contribute something other than money. He argues that welfare systems will face growing demands as work disappears, while taxes in many European countries are already too high to keep increasing.

Italy’s Ministry of University and Research approved about €1.53 million in funding in July 2025. Cassa Centrale’s banking group announced support for an earlier Webfare initiative in October 2022. University of Turin records describe that partnership as an investigation into the feasibility of a mutual platform, including a business plan.

The legal starting point, in Ferraris’s account, is Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). It provides access rights and a separate right to data portability, subject to conditions. The European Data Protection Board explains that portability covers data people provide, including observations of their behaviour, when processing is automated and based on consent or a contract. It excludes information an organisation subsequently creates from those inputs.

That distinction matters to the proposed banks: recovering a person’s activity records is different from obtaining every inference a platform has drawn about them. These rights do not by themselves establish a welfare mechanism or guarantee a commercial return.

AI still depends on humans

Behind the banking example is an argument about the relationship between humans and machines. For a long time, Ferraris says, work and production have been central to how people understand their place in society. Automation challenges that identification.

As machines perform more productive tasks, he believes society needs to reconsider what humans contribute. His answer is need: the desires and purposes that give an activity its value to someone.

“The machine that records us can also transcribe what we are saying,” Ferraris said during our video call. The software was already doing just that. What gave the conversation value, he said, was that someone wanted to ask the questions, he wanted to answer them and someone might want to read the result. “Without need, there is no value.”

For Ferraris, this is also the economic limit of artificial intelligence without human users. Without them, its owners would receive neither their money nor their data. Equally, the information produced would lack the human purposes that make it useful.

Ferraris wants to shift attention from people solely as workers to people as beings with needs. Digital systems record the activities through which those needs are expressed. In his account, those records create a resource that could help support people even as the economic role of their labour diminishes.

‘Digital waste‘

Ferraris also distinguishes what people deliberately publish from the information their actions leave behind. “If I make a story on Instagram, probably I am insincere,” he said. A philosophical argument posted online may be wrong. But the circumstances of posting it leave a different kind of record, he explains.

The time and place of an upload, and the user’s actions before and afterwards, are the kinds of traces he has in mind when discussing “syntactic data” or digital waste.

He regards them as more revealing than a person’s deliberate self-presentation because they are numerous and often involuntary. In his account, they record behaviour with a sincerity that an intentionally crafted message may lack.

Their potential extends beyond commercial profiling, he argues. Records of behaviour could also contribute to scientific knowledge about human beings. This is part of why he considers everyday digital activity a resource whose benefits should reach society more widely.

Webfare and universal basic income

Asked why he favours Webfare over universal basic income, Ferraris focuses on funding. His objection is directed at basic income financed by taxation: it transfers wealth that has already been generated, whereas he wants to realise value from an additional resource.

“It doesn’t rest on a new value,” he said of basic income.

Cash distributions can also draw on assets rather than solely taxation. Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend distributes investment earnings associated with mineral royalties. That is a resource dividend, not evidence that a full universal basic income would necessarily be financially viable.

He also places the proposal between two political models he finds inadequate. In his assessment, the United States fails to redistribute enough wealth, contributing to political discontent. China, he argues, combines redistribution with state control and surveillance of citizens.

He describes the United States as a declining empire and China as a rising one. His objection to the Chinese model is that redistribution without freedom is incompatible with his understanding of democracy and would not work in Europe.

AI literacy and human judgement

Economic redistribution is only part of Ferraris’s response to AI. The other is education: people must be able to ask useful questions and judge the answers they receive.

He contrasts this with technologies whose everyday use requires a narrower set of skills. Driving a car, in his example, requires an understanding of road signs, but does not require the driver to interpret a machine’s account of the world.

AI makes human judgement central to its use. People supply the purposes of a search and assess whether the response meets them. Without that capacity, Ferraris warns, the technology could damage humanity; with it, he believes AI could provide an unprecedented benefit.

His optimistic prospect is what he calls “a humanity empowered”: people able to put questions to machines while exercising their own judgement about the results.

Ilievska co-teaches the AI Literacy course with Claudia Franzè and Rafael Papallas. She said Ferraris had introduced students to a model for sharing the benefits of data more fairly. “Affirmative proposals for harnessing data in the public interest remain relatively scarce in contemporary intellectual debates,” she told en.philenews.

The emphasis on recorded activity also connects Webfare to his earlier philosophy of documentality, which examines the role of records in social reality. Asked whether that theory had evolved into his current work, he rejected the premise. It had helped him recognise the importance of recording when the data economy emerged.

“I am not trying to evolve, I am trying to apply,” he said.

Follow en.philenews on Google News and be the first to know all the news about Cyprus and the world.