The power struggle behind EU foreign policy

Relevant News

The European Commission is increasingly taking the lead in EU diplomacy, while foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas of the European External Action Service (EEAS) struggles to maintain her influence.

The latest sign came this week, as Ursula von der Leyen and Commissioner Dubravka Šuica prepared to travel to Syria and Jordan, while Kallas remains frozen out by Israeli foreign minister Gideon Sa’ar following their diplomatic rupture in June.

This week’s competing diplomatic moves brought the Brussels power struggle into sharp focus: as von der Leyen increases her grip on the regional stage, Kallas is left fighting for a seat at the table.

Von der Leyen’s expanding diplomatic empire

The rivalry reflects a longer-running expansion of the Commission’s role in external relations. The Commission controls many of the economic instruments through which diplomatic pressure could be applied, including trade policy and financial assistance, limiting the EEAS’s real power.

When the European External Action Service (EEAS) was established in 2011, its purpose was to provide the EU with a diplomatic service capable of giving greater coherence to its international representation. Modelled in some respects on a national foreign ministry, it was designed to support the High Representative and coordinate the Union’s foreign policy abroad.

But the EU’s institutional architecture has always contained an inherent tension. The EEAS and the High Representative oversee foreign and security policy, while the Commission controls many of the financial, economic and regulatory instruments that increasingly shape international relations.

Trade, development assistance, humanitarian aid, migration cooperation, energy and investment have all become instruments of European geopolitical influence. These are largely areas in which the Commission has substantial authority.

Under von der Leyen, the Commission has become increasingly visible in these areas, developing direct relationships with foreign governments and taking a more prominent role in international negotiations.

The creation of the Directorate-General for the Middle East, North Africa and the Gulf, headed by Šuica, is a particularly significant example. The new department provides the Commission with a dedicated regional structure and brings together policy areas and financial instruments relating to the region. Its official mandate and responsibilities illustrate the Commission’s growing regional involvement.

Its responsibilities overlap geographically and politically with those of the EEAS, which already maintains diplomatic delegations and regional expertise across the Middle East.

The Commission argues that this arrangement allows the EU to use its economic and financial resources more effectively. But the institutional consequences are difficult to separate from that explanation. By developing its own regional structures and diplomatic relationships, the Commission has acquired additional visibility and influence in an area traditionally associated with the EU’s diplomatic service.

Kallas challenges the rules of the game

The tension became more explicit in September, when Kallas addressed the difficulties of coordinating EU foreign policy under the current institutional arrangement.

She questioned how the system could function when decisions were effectively being taken above her, despite her responsibility for coordinating the Union’s foreign policy.

The High Representative is expected to provide political direction and coherence, but the Commission president evidently has considerable authority over the institution controlling many of the resources required to implement external policies.

This creates the possibility of competing diplomatic initiatives, particularly when the Commission president and the High Representative have different political priorities or approaches to a particular crisis.

According to recent reports from Politico, Kallas was excluded from Europe’s negotiating team in discussions concerning Ukraine. The episode has reinforced questions about her position in international diplomacy, even as she continues to represent the EU in formal foreign affairs meetings and maintain relations with governments around the world.

There is also a wider institutional debate about the future of the EEAS. Proposals to reform the service and transfer certain responsibilities towards the Commission have been discussed by European governments, including France and Germany. Kallas has defended the existing framework, arguing that its shortcomings should be addressed through better coordination rather than institutional replacement.

The Commission, meanwhile, has continued to develop structures and responsibilities that increase its presence in external relations.

Who’s in charge?

In simple terms, Kallas is responsible for articulating the EU’s political position on Israel, Gaza and the wider region, while Šuica and von der Leyen have developed their own diplomatic channels and engagements.

However, Kallas cannot translate political pressure into comprehensive sanctions, without the Commission’s economic instruments, creating a power vacuum in which the Commission has been increasingly ready to exploit.

(Sources: Politico, European Commission, European External Action Service)

Read more:

Follow en.philenews on Google News and be the first to know all the news about Cyprus and the world.